8 Career-Killing Mistakes New Musicians Keep Making (And How to Avoid Them)
Making it in the music industry isn’t just about talent—it’s about strategy, persistence, and avoiding common pitfalls that can derail your career before it even starts (plus often a little luck). Whether you’re a new musician trying to find your footing or a veteran artist looking to refine your approach, knowing what not to do is just as important as knowing what to do.
In this guide, we’ll break down seven career-killing mistakes that many musicians make—and, more importantly, how to avoid them. If you’re serious about making music your career, keep reading to ensure you’re not falling into these all-too-common traps.
1: Buying Fake Streams/Followers
Why It’s a Career Killer
Seriously, we cannot stress this one enough… never buy fake streams or followers! If a service promises a certain amount of streams, followers, likes, or subscribers in a certain amount of time, they are most likely using inorganic bots to achieve results. While it might seem like a good idea to “fake it ‘til you make it” or try to boost your new song—in the long-term buying interaction will heavily hurt you on any platform.
Take for example YouTube; if you buy 10,000 views on your video each account will stream your video for the minimum amount of time to count for a view—which is great for fraudulent streams—but in your analytics will lower your overall watch time per viewer (retention rate) meaning that YouTube will rank your content as non-relevant and not push it. All platforms will operate similarly, while fake streams or followers may look good at first, you are essentially sabatoging your chances of gaining real, organic followers in the long-run… is it really worth it?
Be careful because there are a lot of predatory sites and services that pretend to market your music to real people but are actually buying fake streams; essentially scamming the artist who buys the service.
How to Avoid It
If it seems to good to be true, it probably is: When a service promises a specific amount of streams or followers, it’s most likely bots or a scam.
Learn new marketing methods: Instead of purchasing streams or followers, learn how to run effective ad campaigns instead, using your budget to gain real fans as opposed to fake metrics.
2. Ignoring the Business Side of Music
Why It’s a Career Killer
Many musicians assume that if their music is good enough, success will naturally follow. Unfortunately, that’s rarely the case. The music industry is a business, and if you don’t understand marketing, networking, and revenue streams, you’ll struggle to turn your passion into a sustainable career. You could have the best music in the world, but without proper marketing, sadly, no one will ever hear it.
Today’s market is incredibly oversaturated considering how easily new musicians can record, mix/master, and distribute their music fully independently, so marketing is more important than ever! For more in-depth guides on marketing read this:
How to Avoid It
• Learn the basics of music business: Publishing, royalties, contracts, and distribution.
• Treat your band like a brand: Develop a consistent image, message, and marketing strategy.
• Set up multiple revenue streams: Including merch sales, licensing, streaming, and live shows.
• Invest in professionalism: Have a solid EPK (electronic press kit), biography, and a well-maintained website.
3. Failing to Build a Loyal Fanbase
Why It’s a Career Killer
Some musicians believe that simply putting their music on Spotify or YouTube will be enough to attract listeners. But in today’s overpopulated music scene, fans don’t just find you—you have to find them. Without a dedicated fanbase, even the best music can go unheard.
Another important note is to choose your live shows carefully, while playing out at venues is among the best ways to gain new fans—playing the same venues or for the same people repeatedly will often have less successful results. Sometimes saving the travelin/gas money and using it instead for online marketing will have better results.
How to Avoid It
• Engage with your audience on social media: don’t just post about your music, try to start conversations or ask fans for their feedback.
• Build an email list to connect with fans directly: (email marketing is still incredibly effective and can be used alongside social media).
• Play worthwhile live shows as much as you can: in-person connections turn casual listeners into lifelong fans.
• Offer exclusive content: behind-the-scenes footage, Q and A’s, and real value beyond just your music.
4. Not Investing in Quality Recordings
Why It’s a Career Killer
First impressions matter. If your music sounds unpolished, listeners (and industry professionals) might not take you seriously. Bad production can ruin even the best song. We know mixing/mastering can be incredibly expensive, so if it doesn’t fit in your budget, you can find great resources on YouTube and entire communities on Reddit for learning music production yourself.
How to Avoid It
• If you’re recording at home, learn proper mixing and mastering techniques (or hire someone who knows how).
• Invest in quality equipment—a decent microphone, audio interface, and DAW (Digital Audio Workstation) are essential.
• Consider working with a professional producer or engineer who understands your genre.
• Always compare your mix to popular songs in your genre to ensure it competes musically.
5. Overlooking Live Performance Skills
Why It’s a Career Killer
You can have the best songs in the world, but if you can’t command a stage, you’ll struggle to grow as a live performer. Fans remember high-energy, emotionally engaging performances. A dull live show? Not so much.
A captivating live performance can transform a new listener into a long-time fan, so make sure to treat all shows equally important, but don’t forget to have fun! If you aren’t enjoying your performance, its hard for the audience to!
How to Avoid It
• Rehearse not just your music, but your stage presence—how you interact with the crowd matters.
• Watch live performances from successful artists in your genre to see what works.
• Engage with your audience—eye contact, movement, and confidence go a long way.
• Record your shows and analyze them. What’s working? What feels awkward? Improve from there.
6. Relying Too Much on Social Media Alone
Why It’s a Career Killer
Many musicians think that likes and followers equal success, but social media platforms control your reach. If Instagram or TikTok changes their algorithm, you could lose access to your audience overnight, try not to rely only on one platform.
How to Avoid It
• Diversify your marketing efforts—don’t rely solely on one platform, try to spread your audience across platforms.
• Build your email list—email gives you direct access to your fans.
• Create a website where fans can find your music, tour dates, and merch.
• Engage with your audience in multiple ways—live performances, collaborations, music videos, and press features.
7. Burning Out Too Fast
Why It’s a Career Killer
Many musicians go all-in at the start but lose momentum when things don’t take off quickly. The music industry tends to be a marathon, not a sprint—many of the most successful bands take years before gaining the traction or success that they know today.
How to Avoid It
• Set realistic goals—break big goals into smaller, achievable milestones.
• Develop a sustainable routine—balance songwriting, promotion, and rest.
• Surround yourself with a supportive community—connect with other musicians, mentors, and industry professionals.
• Remember why you started—passion fuels longevity.
8. Expecting Overnight Success
Why It’s a Career Killer
One viral moment won’t build a career. Many musicians give up too soon because they expect instant results. The truth? Success in music takes time, consistent effort, and patience.
How to Avoid It
• Celebrate small wins—gaining 10 real fans is better than 10,000 fake streams.
• Keep learning, improving, and adapting to industry changes.
• Focus on the long-term journey instead of chasing short-term validation.
• Keep making music because you love it, not just because you want fame.
Final Thoughts: Success Is About Smart Choices
Avoiding these eight career-killing mistakes won’t guarantee instant success, but it will set you up for long-term growth in the music industry. Music is an art, but it’s also a business. Treat it as both, stay consistent, and never stop improving. You can set yourself apart by long-term consistency and hard work.
Now it’s your turn:
What’s the biggest challenge you’ve faced as a musician? Drop a comment below or share your experiences with us!
Want access to our full collection of music guides, marketing strategies, and music contact list?
Sign up for our Musician Vault membership with our limited time discount here or check out more free music guides.
Thanks for reading!
- Subscribe to our Metal News Email Newsletter for free!
- Support The Metalverse and go ad-free.
- Check out our Musician Vault with in-depth music guides
- Metal Merch available here
- Follow us on Social Media | Instagram | Facebook | X (Twitter)
